论坛公告:应用容器安全指南(SP800-190)中文版   美国政府宣布禁用卡巴斯基软件   《中华人民共和国网络安全法》讨论帖   新手报到专用帖   【论坛公告】关于本站广告贴泛滥问题的整理通知   

当前时区为 UTC + 8 小时


发表新帖 回复这个主题  [ 11 篇帖子 ] 
作者 内容
 文章标题 : All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-06-04 14:20 
离线
新手

注册: 2009-08-25 15:58
最近: 2012-01-26 09:21
拥有: 4.00 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 43 点
帖子: 2
:?:


--------本帖迄今已累计获得1安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-06-04 19:58 
离线
初级用户

注册: 2008-10-23 16:45
最近: 2014-05-06 09:01
拥有: 463.20 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 719 点
帖子: 46
国外网友的总结

The below refers to AIO V5
Chapter 3 - Information Security and Risk Mgmnt.
P63. A clearer identification of ISO 27001 and 27002.
P64 Definitions for 27001,27002, 27004, 27005, 27006 and 27799
P 82 Mentioning of AS/NZS

Conclusion, more emphasis is put on certifications for Information System Mgmnt COSO/COBIT/FRAP/ISO 27001 ..etc and how to achieve those certifications and 6 more questions have been added to the book regarding these.

Chapter 4 Access Control
P.177-178 GML/SGML/HTML/XML/SPML/XACML/SAML

Conclusion: Almost the same, just a few notes about the markup languages above. And Total No. of Qs is 31.

Chapter 5 Security Architecture and Design
P. 318-320 Virtual Machines, definitions and their usage and benefits.

Conclusion, generally the same, was expecting to see more on CC and less on Orange Book or some more Rainbow color definitions. Number of Qs : 25 same as AIO V4.


Chapter 6 Environmental and Physical Security
I could not find any relevant changes, this chapter seems identical in both books including the questions. As a side note, this chapter is only 20 pages in OIG V1.

Chapter 7 Telecommunications and Network Security
P 535 More info on DHCP
P 605 More info on SIP
Basically, this chapter disappointed me most, since Teleco and Networks does play a major part in my job, I thought this chapter would have the errors of AIO V4 fixed. In P502 FTP and SSH are still under UDP in Page 575 England is still a Top Level Domain. There are not a lot of differences between V4 and V5 but if anything the more obvious errors in V4 should have been corrected before V5 was published since other changes are not so obvious.
Conclusion, a lot of updated images more info on DHCP and SIP, most of errors are still there and Questions are the same as in AIO V 4.

Chapter 8 Cryptography
P 680-683 More info on Steganography "Carrier, Null Cipher, Stego-medium, Payload, LSB)
P 726 CMAC mentioned
Conclusion: A few errors in V4 are fixed, Questions are the same.

Chapter 9 BCP RDP
I did not note any notable differences, mainly a few errors were fixed and the number of questions was increased to 27. When compared to the OIG chapter of BCP/RDP I thought I was reading some Marsian language in the OIG book.

Chapter 10 Legal, Regulations, Compliance and Investigations.
Generally the same two new gray boxes :
P- 874 Personal Privacy Protection
P-897 The Australian Emergency Response Team Guidelines For Computer
Forensics
No of questions is the same.

Chapter 11 Application Security
P 968 Added a lot of development methods
P970 - 971 Secure Design Methodology - Secure Development Methodology - Secure Testing
P977 More emphasis on G Languages.
P 993 SOAP

Chapter 12 Operation Security
Seems the same for me apart from one extra questions


--------本帖迄今已累计获得95安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-06-28 21:23 
离线
新手

注册: 2010-04-17 21:36
最近: 2011-08-07 14:17
拥有: 48.00 安全币

奖励: 1 安全币
在线: 0 点
帖子: 4
第十章法律部分至少有一半以上内容是在第5版中新加的,其他章节差别不大。


--------本帖迄今已累计获得14安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-07-15 10:53 
离线
新手

注册: 2010-07-15 08:57
最近: 2010-07-16 17:58
拥有: 6.00 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 0 点
帖子: 12
good


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-11-24 10:23 
离线
新手

注册: 2007-03-18 22:21
最近: 2011-04-28 12:52
拥有: 20.20 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 401 点
帖子: 18
地址: 上海
明年的考试用什么版本?第五版吗?


--------本帖迄今已累计获得4安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2010-11-24 10:27 
离线
高级用户

注册: 2008-09-19 14:14
最近: 2013-06-14 12:49
拥有: 1,233.40 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 1321 点
帖子: 185
kybest 写道:
国外网友的总结

The below refers to AIO V5
Chapter 3 - Information Security and Risk Mgmnt.
P63. A clearer identification of ISO 27001 and 27002.
P64 Definitions for 27001,27002, 27004, 27005, 27006 and 27799
P 82 Mentioning of AS/NZS

Conclusion, more emphasis is put on certifications for Information System Mgmnt COSO/COBIT/FRAP/ISO 27001 ..etc and how to achieve those certifications and 6 more questions have been added to the book regarding these.

Chapter 4 Access Control
P.177-178 GML/SGML/HTML/XML/SPML/XACML/SAML

Conclusion: Almost the same, just a few notes about the markup languages above. And Total No. of Qs is 31.

Chapter 5 Security Architecture and Design
P. 318-320 Virtual Machines, definitions and their usage and benefits.

Conclusion, generally the same, was expecting to see more on CC and less on Orange Book or some more Rainbow color definitions. Number of Qs : 25 same as AIO V4.


Chapter 6 Environmental and Physical Security
I could not find any relevant changes, this chapter seems identical in both books including the questions. As a side note, this chapter is only 20 pages in OIG V1.

Chapter 7 Telecommunications and Network Security
P 535 More info on DHCP
P 605 More info on SIP
Basically, this chapter disappointed me most, since Teleco and Networks does play a major part in my job, I thought this chapter would have the errors of AIO V4 fixed. In P502 FTP and SSH are still under UDP in Page 575 England is still a Top Level Domain. There are not a lot of differences between V4 and V5 but if anything the more obvious errors in V4 should have been corrected before V5 was published since other changes are not so obvious.
Conclusion, a lot of updated images more info on DHCP and SIP, most of errors are still there and Questions are the same as in AIO V 4.

Chapter 8 Cryptography
P 680-683 More info on Steganography "Carrier, Null Cipher, Stego-medium, Payload, LSB)
P 726 CMAC mentioned
Conclusion: A few errors in V4 are fixed, Questions are the same.

Chapter 9 BCP RDP
I did not note any notable differences, mainly a few errors were fixed and the number of questions was increased to 27. When compared to the OIG chapter of BCP/RDP I thought I was reading some Marsian language in the OIG book.

Chapter 10 Legal, Regulations, Compliance and Investigations.
Generally the same two new gray boxes :
P- 874 Personal Privacy Protection
P-897 The Australian Emergency Response Team Guidelines For Computer
Forensics
No of questions is the same.

Chapter 11 Application Security
P 968 Added a lot of development methods
P970 - 971 Secure Design Methodology - Secure Development Methodology - Secure Testing
P977 More emphasis on G Languages.
P 993 SOAP

Chapter 12 Operation Security
Seems the same for me apart from one extra questions




谢谢楼上的,没币感谢,口头致意。


--------本帖迄今已累计获得5安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2011-01-13 12:22 
离线
超级用户

注册: 2009-12-13 11:09
最近: 2014-10-26 14:05
拥有: 439.00 安全币

奖励: 5848 安全币
在线: 999 点
帖子: 320
这么看起来诧异很小啊


--------本帖迄今已累计获得3安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2011-01-15 14:45 
离线
新手

注册: 2011-01-15 10:58
最近: 2011-01-17 22:15
拥有: 86.00 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 0 点
帖子: 2
請問如果2011年考試的話是要看v5的嗎比較好嗎?還是其實對考試來說~V4 or V5都差不多呢?


--------本帖迄今已累计获得6安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2011-01-15 19:56 
离线
中级用户

注册: 2005-08-04 16:24
最近: 2017-11-02 22:35
拥有: 8,156.30 安全币

奖励: 65 安全币
在线: 4715 点
帖子: 68
v4和v5真的差别不大,而且隔的时间相当长,不清楚出v5的真正含义
v2和v4的差别倒是非常大


--------本帖迄今已累计获得4安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2011-03-29 03:13 
离线
中级用户

注册: 2007-06-07 16:40
最近: 2014-12-05 13:26
拥有: 1,939.40 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 2056 点
帖子: 84
正在看第五版中,还没看完。个人意见:所有这些围绕最新技术架构以及法律条文的发展而改变,2009年5月到2010年5月,技术上的变化不大,所以整体来说第四版和第五版的差异不大。
详细的差异,等看完后写下。


--------本帖迄今已累计获得13安全币用户奖励--------


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
 文章标题 : Re: All in One 第五版与V4到底区别在哪里呢,有谁看过吗?
帖子发表于 : 2011-11-18 09:42 
离线
新手

关注按钮

注册: 2011-06-26 12:32
最近: 2017-07-03 14:10
拥有: 55.00 安全币

奖励: 0 安全币
在线: 514 点
帖子: 12
从网上的定价来看V5比V4便宜 所以还没买书的 可以考虑下V5吧


回到顶部
 奖励本帖 用户资料  
 
显示帖子 :  排序  
发表新帖 回复这个主题  [ 11 篇帖子 ] 

当前时区为 UTC + 8 小时


在线用户

正在浏览此版面的用户:没有注册用户 和 1 位游客


不能 在这个版面发表主题
不能 在这个版面回复主题
不能 在这个版面编辑帖子
不能 在这个版面删除帖子
不能 在这个版面提交附件

前往 :  
cron
华安信达(CISPS.org) ©2003 - 2012